0
items in Cart
Home
Our Story
Gift Cards
Catering
Order Online
0
items in Cart
Home
Our Story
Gift Cards
Catering
Order Online
Group Order
Tasty Rewards
Sign Up For Deals
Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant
Online Ordering Menu
1 Main St
Garnerville, NY 10923
(845) 429-4862
10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
94% of 228 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability
Expand Menu
MONDAY SPECIAL
Large Pie, Penne Vodka Dinner & Garlic Knots
$36.99+
TUESDAY SPECIAL
Large Pie, Gnocchi Ala Vodka Dinner & Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Feeds 4-5.
$36.99+
WEDNESDAY SPECIAL
Large Pie, Stuffed Shells Ala Vodka Dinner, Garlic Knots & 2-Liter Soda
Feeds 4.
$37.99+
THURSDAY SPECIAL
Large Pie & 10 Wings
$27.99+
SUNDAY SPECIAL
Large Pie & Zeppoles
Feeds 3-4.
$21.99+
SPECIALS
Every Day Special 1
Large pie, garlic knots, 10 pieces chicken wings, zeppoles & your choice of a 2-liter soda.
$36.95
#2
Large Plain Pie, Large Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie, 1 Order Mozzarella Sticks & 2-Liter Soda Feeds 8.
$49.95+
#3
Penna Vodka Dinner, Large Sicilian Pie, Large House Salad & 2-Liter Soda. Feeds 6-8. Sicilian pie includes 12 slices.
$39.95+
APPETIZERS
Mussels
$16.99+
Fried Calamari
Served with a side of marinara sauce.
$14.99+
Buffalo Calamari
Served with bleu cheese.
$15.99+
Garlic Knots
6 pieces. Served with marinara sauce.
$5.99+
Garlic Bread
$5.99+
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
$6.99+
Chicken Tenders
5 pieces. Served with honey mustard.
$11.99+
French Fries
$6.99+
Curly Fries
$8.99+
Garlic Fries
$10.99+
Chicken Wings
$15.99+
Boneless Wings
$14.99+
Onion Rings
$7.99+
Mozzarella Sticks
7 pieces. Served with marinara sauce.
$10.99+
Rice Ball (3)
$12.99+
Meatballs (2)
$8.99+
Sausage
$8.99+
Fried Ravioli
Served with marinara sauce.
$12.99+
Jalapeno Poppers
$8.99+
Zucchini Sticks
Served with tzatziki sauce.
$10.99+
Sweet Potato Fries
$8.99+
Loaded Bacon Ranch Fries
With melted American cheese.
$9.99+
SOUPS
Chicken Noodle Soup
$6.95+
Pasta Fagioli Soup
$6.95+
Italian Wedding Soup
$6.95+
Lentil Soup
$6.95+
Sea Food Soup
$9.95+
SALADS
Served with your choice of dressing.
House Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber and black olives.
$8.99+
Caesar Salad
Lettuce, Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese, and croutons.
$9.99+
Caprese Salad
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and olive oil.
$11.99+
Eggplant Salad
House Salad with eggplant, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers.
$11.99+
OIP Salad
Romaine, olives, tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and mushrooms tossed with olive oil & balsamic.
$10.99+
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Buffalo chicken, tomatoes, and onions.
$12.99+
Greek Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, red peppers, kalamata olives, and feta cheese with balsamic dressing.
$10.99+
NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA
Personal Pie
$13.99+
Gourmet Personal Pie
$18.99+
Personal Cauliflower
$16.99+
Gourmet Personal Cauliflower
$20.99+
12" Gluten Free Pizza
$18.99+
12" Gourmet Gluten Free Pizza
$22.99+
CYO Sicilian Pizza
$23.99+
GOURMET PIZZAS
Bruschetta Thin Square Pizza
Fresh garlic, basil, marinara sauce, and mozzarella served on a deep dish crust.
$24.99+
Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza
$23.95+
Grandma Thin Square Pizza
Fresh garlic, basil, marinara sauce, and mozzarella served on a deep dish crust.
$24.99+
Margarita Pizza
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and oregano.
$23.99+
Round Sicilian Deep-Dish Pizza
Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$25.99+
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Sauteed shrimp with scampi sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$29.99+
Tortellini Pesto Pizza
$24.45+
Cheese Pizza
Tomato sauce, oregano and mozzarella cheese.
$16.99+
Grandma Pizza
Fresh garlic, marinara, mozzarella cheese, and basil.
$21.99+
White Pizza
Ricotta sauce, mozzarella cheese topped with ricotta.
$22.99+
Veggie Pizza
Green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, tomatoes, spinach, and onions.
$22.99+
Ravioli Vodka Pizza
Ravioli mixed with vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$23.99+
Taco Pizza
Ground beef, lttuce, tomato, sour cream, cheddar cheese, and salsa.
$27.99+
Garlic Chicken Parm Pizza
Chicken cutlet, fresh garlic, and mozzarella cheese.
$22.99+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chicken cutlet, bacon, and mozzarella cheese topped with ranch.
$23.99+
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza
Chicken cutlet, broccoli, and fresh mozzarella.
$24.99+
Heathers Vodka Pizza
Creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
$22.99+
Bruchetta Pizza
Sauteed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and chopped onions.
$22.99+
Chicken Vodka Pizza
Chicken cutlet, vodka sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
$23.99+
Stuffed Teriyaki Cheesesteak Pie
Cheesesteak, teriyaki sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$30.95+
Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chipotle, bacon, ranch, topped with mozzarella cheese.
$24.99+
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken cutlet tossed in BBQ sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$23.99+
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Chicken cutlet with marinara and mozzarella cheese.
$22.99+
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken cutlet mixed with buffalo sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$22.99+
Fresca Pizza
Zucchini, tomatoes, onions & fresh mozzarella.
$22.99+
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and meatball topped with mozzarella cheese.
$23.99+
Penne Vodka Pizza
Penne with our house vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$22.99+
OIP Salad Pizza
Romaine lettuce, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, fresh mozzarella, and Parmesan.
$24.99+
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
$23.99+
Cheese Steak Pizza
Philly cheesesteak, onions, mozzarella cheese, and American cheese.
$23.99+
Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza
Tomato sauce, pepperoni, and hot honey sauce.
$22.99+
Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza
Chicken cutlet doused in red chili sauce and topped with mozzarella.
$22.99+
PIZZA BY THE SLICE
Cheese Slice
$3.70+
Slice with 1-Topping
$4.50+
Pepperoni Slice
$3.70+
Grandma Slice
Fresh garlic, marinara, mozzarella cheese, and basil.
$4.25+
Bruchetta Slice
Sauteed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and chopped onions.
$4.25+
Ravioli Vodka Slice
Ravioli mixed with vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$4.25+
Meat Lovers Slice
Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and meatball topped with mozzarella cheese.
$4.25+
Chicken Parmigiana Slice
Chicken cutlet with marinara and mozzarella cheese.
$4.25+
Sweet Chili Chicken Slice
Chicken cutlet doused in red chili sauce and topped with mozzarella.
$4.25+
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Chicken cutlet mixed with buffalo sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$4.25+
BBQ Chicken Slice
Chicken cutlet tossed in BBQ sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$4.25+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Chicken cutlet, bacon, and mozzarella cheese topped with ranch.
$4.25+
Chicken Alfredo Slice
$4.25+
Veggie Slice
Green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, tomatoes, spinach, and onions.
$4.25+
Penne Vodka Slice
Penne with our house vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$4.25+
Heathers Vodka Slice
Creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
$4.25+
Margarita Slice
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and oregano.
$4.25+
Chicken & Broccoli Slice
Chicken cutlet, broccoli, and fresh mozzarella.
$4.25+
Sicilian Slice
$4.25+
White Slice
Ricotta sauce, mozzarella cheese topped with ricotta.
$4.25+
CALZONES & STROMBOLIS
All calzones served with marinara sauce.
Cheese Calzone
Mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
$9.99+
Stromboli
Ham, salami, sausage, and mozzarella cheese.
$8.99+
Family Stromboli (Feeds 10)
Ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese.
$44.95+
ROLLS
All calzones & rolls served with marinara sauce.
Broccoli Roll
Broccoli, mozzarella, garlic and oil.
$7.99+
Sausage Roll
Ham, salami, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.
$8.99+
Chicken Roll
Chicken cutlet, marinara and mozzarella cheese.
$7.99+
Spinach Roll
Spinach, mozzarella cheese, garlic and oil.
$7.99+
Buffalo Chicken Roll
Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.
$8.99+
LUNCH ENTREES
Served with bread.
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken cutlet with homemade marinara sauce.
$14.99+
Chicken Alla Vodka
Chicken parm smothered in our homemade vodka sauce.
$14.99+
Chicken Francaise
Made with homemade lemon gravy.
$14.99+
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken cutlet in our house made creamy Alfredo sauce topped with parsley.
$14.99+
Chicken Marsala
Made with our homemade brown gravy with fresh mushrooms.
$14.99+
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant in house marinara topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.
$14.99+
Eggplant Rollatini
Breaded eggplant rolled in ricotta cheese topped with marinara sauce.
$14.99+
Veal Parmigiana
Veal breaded in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$14.99+
DINNER ENTREES
Served with salad, bread, and a choice of ziti or spaghetti.
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken cutlet with homemade marinara sauce.
$22.95+
Chicken Alla Vodka
Chicken parm smothered in our homemade vodka sauce.
$22.95+
Chicken Francaise
Made with homemade lemon gravy.
$22.95+
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken cutlet in our house made creamy Alfredo sauce topped with parsley.
$22.95+
Chicken Marsala
Made with our homemade brown gravy with fresh mushrooms.
$22.95+
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant in house marinara topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.
$22.95+
Eggplant Rollatini
Breaded eggplant rolled in ricotta cheese topped with marinara sauce.
$22.95+
Veal Parmigiana
Veal breaded in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$22.95+
FAMILY ENTREES
Served with salad, bread, and a choice of ziti or spaghetti.
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken cutlet with homemade marinara sauce.
$49.99+
Chicken Alla Vodka
Chicken parm smothered in our homemade vodka sauce.
$49.99+
Chicken Francaise
Made with homemade lemon gravy.
$49.99+
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken cutlet in our house made creamy Alfredo sauce topped with parsley.
$49.99+
Chicken Marsala
Made with our homemade brown gravy with fresh mushrooms.
$49.99+
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant in house marinara topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.
$49.99+
Eggplant Rollatini
Breaded eggplant rolled in ricotta cheese topped with marinara sauce.
$49.99+
Veal Parmigiana
Veal breaded in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
$49.99+
PASTA DISHES
Whole wheat pasta & gluten-free pasta are available. All lunches come with bread only. Dinners are served with salad & bread and include House Dressing.
Gnocchi Ala Pesto
Potato pasta mixed with homemade pesto sauce.
$12.99+
Gnocchi Alfredo with Bacon
Potato pasta smothered in homemade Alfredo sauce topped with bacon.
$13.99+
Manicotti Ala Vodka
Large pasta tubes stuffed with ricotta cheese and rolled with melted mozzarella cheese topped with vodka sauce.
$13.99+
Manicotti Pasta
Large pasta tubes stuffed with ricotta cheese rolled with marinara.
$11.99+
Pasta Primavera
Broccoli, spinach, zucchini, mushrooms, and carrots served in garlic & oil or vodka sauce.
$11.95+
Spinach Ravioli with Garlic & Oil Pasta
$10.95+
Stuffed Shells Ala Vodka
Ricotta stuffed shells covered in house vodka sauce.
$12.99+
Stuffed Shells Pasta
Pasta rolled in ricotta cheese in house made marinara.
$11.99+
Ziti or Spaghetti Bolognese Pasta
Penne marinara with meat sauce.
$11.99+
Ziti or Spaghetti with Meatballs Pasta
$11.99+
Ziti or Spaghetti Marinara Pasta
Ziti or spaghetti smothered in our homemade marinara.
$12.99+
Penne Vodka Pasta
Penne in our homemade vodka sauce.
$12.99+
Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta
Fettuccine tossed with butter and Parmesan cheese.
$12.99+
Baked Ziti Pasta
Penne pasta in house made marinara with melted mozzarella.
$12.99+
Lasagna
Ground beef, ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella, and marinara sauce.
$12.99+
Ravioli Pasta
Cheese ravioli with marinara sauce.
$12.99+
Ravioli Alla Vodka Pasta
Cheese ravioli with vodka sauce.
$12.99+
Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe Garlic & Oil Pasta
Cavatelli pasta in garlic and oil.
$12.99+
Cavatelli with Garlic & Oil Pasta
Cavatelli pasta in garlic and oil.
$12.99+
Gnocchi Ala Vodka
Potato pasta and our house made vodka sauce.
$12.99+
Tortellini Alfredo Pasta
Tortellini pasta in our homemade Alfredo sauce.
$12.99+
SEAFOOD
Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp with a garlic white wine and butter sauce.
$22.99+
Shrimp Alfredo
Shrimp over penne with our homemade Alfredo sauce.
$22.99+
Shrimp Parmigiana
Shrimp with our house marinara over penne.
$22.99+
Seafood Fra Diablo
Mussels, calamari, and shrimp over linguini.
$22.99+
SIGNATURE GARLIC KNOT SLIDERS
Chicken Parmigiana Slider
Chicken cutlet with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.
$6.99+
Grilled Chicken Slider
Chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella & roasted red peppers.
$6.99+
Buffalo Chicken Slider
Buffalo chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella.
$6.99+
Eggplant Slider
Eggplant with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & balsamic vinaigrette.
$6.99+
Eggplant Parmigiana Slider
Fried eggplant with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.
$6.99+
Pepperoni Slider
Pepperoni with mozzarella cheese.
$6.99+
Teriyaki Cheesesteak Slider
$6.99+
Chicken Parm Ala Vodka Slider
$6.99+
Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Slider
$6.99+
PANINIS
All paninis are made with fresh in-house bread and are served with fries or macaroni salad.
Grilled Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella & roasted red peppers.
$13.99+
Buffalo Chicken Panini
Buffalo chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato & fresh mozzarella.
$13.99+
Eggplant & Swiss Panini
Fried eggplant, Swiss cheese & spinach.
$13.99+
HOT HEROES
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Chicken cutlet, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$12.99+
Chicken Vodka Hero
Chicken cutlet, vodka sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$13.99+
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Meatball, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$12.99+
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Fried eggplant, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$12.99+
Philly Cheese Steak Hero
Steak, onions and American cheese.
$12.99+
The Godfather Hero
Broccoli rabe in garlic & oil, fresh mozzarella & grilled chicken.
$13.99+
Bella Chicken Hero
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, olive oil & balsamic vinegar.
$13.99+
San Antonio Hero
Chicken cutlet, bacon, secret house BBQ sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$13.99+
Santa Fe Hero
Chicken cutlet, bacon, American cheese, & Russian dressing.
$13.99+
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
Shrimp, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$13.99+
Veal Parmigiana Hero
Veal, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$13.99+
Chicken Avocado Hero
Grilled chicken, lettuce, bacon, tomato, avocado, Swiss & mayo.
$13.99+
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch and mozzarella cheese.
$13.99+
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken cutlet and fresh mozzarella cheese tossed in buffalo sauce.
$13.99+
COLD HEROES
Now using Boar's Head.
Italian Hero
Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato & onion.
$12.99+
Turkey Hero
Turkey, lettuce, tomato, mayo and American cheese.
$12.99+
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, mayo and American cheese.
$12.99+
Grilled Chicken Hero
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, and roasted red peppers.
$12.99+
WRAPS
All wraps come with a side of fries or macaroni salad.
The God Mother Wrap
Broccoli rabe in garlic, fresh mozzarella & grilled chicken
$13.99+
Greek Wrap
Grilled chicken, arugula, red onions, feta cheese & black olives
$13.99+
Turkey Club Wrap
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo
$13.99+
Eggplant Wrap
Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & prosciutto
$13.99+
Southern Wrap
Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, tomato, swiss cheese & mayo
$13.99+
Pesto Wrap
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers tossed in pesto sauce
$13.99+
Chicken Cutlet
Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, mayo and American cheese.
$13.99+
Sweet Chili Wrap
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, and cilantro tossed in sweet red chili sauce
$13.99+
KIDS MENU
Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries
3 pieces chicken fingers
$10.99+
Kid's Mozzarella Sticks & Fries
4 pieces of mozzarella sticks
$10.99+
Kid's Baked Ziti
$10.99+
Kid's Penne Vodka
$10.99+
DESSERTS
Cannoli
$4.25
Brownie
$3.95
Zeppoles
$6.99
Key Lime Pie
$4.75
Tiramisu
$4.75
Red Velvet
$4.75
Oreo Cake
$4.75
Nutella Filled Zeppoles
$10.99
Cannoli-Filled Zeppoles
$10.99
BEVERAGES
Arizona
$1.75
Water
$1.50
20 Oz. Drink
$2.85
Snapple
$2.85
Gatorade
$2.95
2-Liter
$4.50
SAUCES TO-GO
Marinara Sauce (16 oz)
$6.99
Vodka Sauce (16 oz)
$8.99
Alfredo Sauce (16 oz)
$8.99
Pesto Sauce (16 oz)
$8.99
CATERING - APPETIZERS
Chicken Tenders
$57.00+
Mussels
$65.00+
Fried Calamari
$61.00+
Chicken Wings
$74.99+
Boneless Wings
$74.99+
Onion Rings
$39.00+
Mozzarella Sticks
$49.00+
Fried Ravioli
$59.00+
Clams Oreganata
$75.00+
Zucchini Sticks
$55.00+
Fried Shrimp
$69.00+
Garlic Knot Sliders
$45.00+
Chicken Wings
$66.99+
Garlic Knot Sliders
$55.00+
CATERING - SALADS
Antipasto Salad
Prosciutto, provolone, salami over mixed greens.
$88.00+
Potato Salad
$38.00+
Macaroni Salad
$38.00+
Bruschetta
$47.00+
House Salad
$56.00+
OIP Salad
Romaine, olives, tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and mushrooms tossed with olive oil & balsamic)
$62.00+
Chef Salad
Turkey & Swiss over house salad.
$65.00+
Caesar Salad
$65.00+
Greek Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, red peppers, kalamata olives, and feta cheese with balsamic dressing.
$65.00+
Fresh Mozzarella Salad
$65.00+
Arugula Salad
Tomatoes, red onions, avocado, walnuts, lemon & olive oil dressing.
$51.00+
Cobb Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, two hard-boiled eggs, bacon & ranch dressing.
$58.00+
CATERING - PASTA
Penne Vodka Pasta
$57.00+
Baked Ziti Pasta
$57.00+
Lasagna
$65.00+
Ziti or Spaghetti Bolognese Pasta
$62.00+
Ziti or Spaghetti Marinara Pasta
$48.00+
Cavatelli with Garlic & Oil Pasta
$55.00+
Tortellini Pesto Pasta
$65.00+
Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta
$57.00+
CATERING - ENTREES
Chicken Parmigiana
$60.00+
Chicken Alla Vodka
$65.00+
Chicken Marsala
$65.00+
Chicken Francaise
$65.00+
Chicken Scarpiello
$65.00+
Chicken Cacciatore
$65.00+
Veal Marsala
$75.00+
Eggplant Parmigiana
$60.00+
Eggplant Rollatini
$65.00+
Sausage & Peppers
$65.00+
Meatballs
$55.00+
Shrimp Fra Diablo
$75.00+
Spaghetti in Red or White Clam Sauce
$65.00+
Shrimp Scampi
$72.00+
CATERING - HEROES
Priced per foot. We need a day in advance notice for all hero orders!
Italian Hero
Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato & onion.
$26.95
American Hero
$27.95
Chicken Cutlet Hero
$26.95
Turkey & Cheese Hero
$26.95
Tuna Hero
$29.95
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
$27.95
Wrap Platter
$99.00
CATERING - PACKAGES
Package #1
$135.00
Package #2
$130.00
Your cart is empty.
Close Cart
Checkout
$0.00
Loading, please wait.
View Cart
0
$0.00